Fortune Telling
- Cody Thomas Rounds
- Aug 12
- 14 min read
This article is part of the Cognitive Distortions: Unpacked Series
Explore the full Series HERE
5 Key Points
Understanding Fortune Telling in Psychology: This point explains how the cognitive distortion of fortune telling involves making negative predictions without solid evidence. It clarifies that this thought pattern is a form of cognitive bias where future outcomes are assumed to be negative.
The Emotional Toll of Negative Predictions: This point focuses on the emotional consequences of fortune telling, such as increased anxiety and stress. It highlights how anticipating a negative future can lead to feelings of dread and can impact one's ability to take action.
Why We Engage in Fortune Telling: This point explores the psychological roots of this thought pattern, including its link to fear and a need for control. It suggests that by predicting the worst, a person may feel they are preparing for a difficult outcome, even though it may not be true.
Recognizing Fortune Telling in Daily Life: This point provides concrete, relatable examples of how fortune telling manifests in everyday situations. It helps readers identify this distortion in their own thoughts, from social interactions to professional settings.
Challenging Your Negative Forecasts: This point offers actionable advice on how to confront and reframe fortune-telling thoughts. It emphasizes the importance of grounding your thinking in evidence and focusing on the present moment instead of a feared future.
A Deeper Definition
Fortune telling is a cognitive distortion characterized by the tendency to predict a negative outcome without any objective basis. This form of predictive thinking can manifest as an unwavering certainty about future events, often leading you to believe you can foresee failure, disappointment, or rejection. At its core, this distortion is a form of preemptive self-sabotage, where the imagined future becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. This section explores the psychological mechanisms and triggers that contribute to this distortion, providing a more comprehensive understanding of its roots and effects.
Psychological Underpinnings At the heart of fortune telling is a deep-seated need for certainty and control, a psychological driver that seeks to manage the inherent ambiguity of life. By predicting a negative future, your mind may be attempting to prepare you for a perceived inevitable failure, creating a sense of preparedness that, ironically, can prevent you from taking positive action. This preemptive certainty is often linked to anxiety, as your mind may conclude that it is safer to anticipate the worst-case scenario. This distortion can be a protective mechanism, where the fear of the unknown is replaced with the "known" fear of failure, offering a false sense of control over an uncertain future. This pattern is often reinforced by a cognitive bias known as the availability heuristic, where you overestimate the likelihood of events that are easier to recall. If you have a memory of a past failure, your mind may readily conjure a similar outcome for a future event, solidifying your negative prediction.
Cognitive Mechanisms Beyond the need for control, fortune telling operates through several cognitive mechanisms. One of the most significant is negative framing, where you interpret a neutral or even positive situation in a negative light. For example, a new project at work isn't seen as an opportunity for growth, but as a chance to fail. Your mind also engages in catastrophizing, a related distortion where you magnify the consequences of a potential negative event. A small mistake in a presentation isn’t just an error; it’s a career-ending disaster. These mechanisms work in concert to build a seemingly logical, albeit false, narrative of a negative future. The belief that you possess a unique insight into the future, a kind of predictive power, fuels this distortion, making it difficult to challenge.
Common Triggers Fortune telling can be triggered by a wide range of situations where the outcome is uncertain and there is a high-stakes component. These include:
Public Speaking or Performance: The pressure to perform well in front of others can easily activate fortune telling. You might tell yourself, “I’m going to forget my lines, my voice will shake, and everyone will see how unprepared I am,” even if you have practiced for weeks. This is a common trigger because the outcome is both public and important, and the fear of social judgment is a powerful motivator for these negative predictions. The anticipation of failure becomes a form of self-preservation, a way to brace yourself for the perceived inevitable criticism.
First-Time Experiences: Starting a new job, going on a first date, or trying a new hobby can trigger this distortion. The lack of prior experience means there is no evidence to counter the negative prediction. Your mind may jump to conclusions like, “I’ll be terrible at this and make a fool of myself,” or “This will be a complete disaster and I’ll be left feeling more alone than before.” The novelty of the situation leaves a vacuum that fortune telling readily fills with worst-case scenarios.
High-Pressure Social Situations: Social events can be a breeding ground for fortune telling. For instance, before a party, you might think, “Nobody will talk to me, I’ll stand in the corner all night, and I’ll look pathetic.” This can lead to increased anxiety and a self-fulfilling prophecy of social isolation, as your anticipation of a negative outcome makes you less likely to engage. This fear of being rejected or judged socially is a powerful fuel for the fire of fortune-telling.
By understanding the psychological underpinnings, cognitive mechanisms, and common triggers of fortune telling, you can begin to recognize when you are engaging in this distortion. This awareness is the first step toward challenging these negative predictions and building a more balanced and grounded perspective.
How It Feels to You
Experiencing fortune telling can profoundly impact your emotional and cognitive well-being. This cognitive distortion creates an internal state of constant dread and anxiety, as you are convinced that a negative outcome is not only possible, but inevitable. You are not simply worried about the future; you are living in a future you have already decided will be bad. This pre-determined narrative can lead to a pervasive sense of powerlessness and can significantly diminish your quality of life.
Emotional Impact When you engage in fortune telling, the emotional impact is immediate and significant. You may feel a persistent sense of dread and unease. This can lead to a state of heightened anxiety, as your mind is consumed with anticipating a negative outcome. You might feel a weight on your chest, a knot in your stomach, or a general sense of being on edge. These physical sensations are a direct result of your mind's preoccupation with a feared future. This cycle of anxiety can be debilitating, making it difficult to feel present or to enjoy what is happening in the moment. The constant low-grade stress can also lead to symptoms like irritability, fatigue, and difficulty concentrating, as your mental and emotional resources are drained by the imagined threats of the future.
Cognitive Impact Cognitively, fortune telling can be incredibly limiting. It prevents you from seeing other possible outcomes and can lead to a narrow, pessimistic view of the future. You may find yourself unable to consider any positive possibilities, as your mind is already fixated on the negative forecast. This can hinder your ability to plan effectively or to take risks, as you have already decided that your efforts will be futile. The belief that you know the future can also prevent you from putting in the necessary effort, as you may think, "Why bother trying? I already know it's not going to work out." This apathetic mindset becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, not because the future was predetermined, but because you acted in a way that ensured it would be. This distortion closes off possibilities, turning a world full of potential into a series of pre-ordained failures.
The Vicious Cycle of Prediction and Avoidance Fortune telling often initiates a vicious cycle. You predict a negative outcome, which leads to feelings of anxiety and dread. To alleviate this discomfort, you might avoid the situation entirely. For example, you predict your presentation will be a disaster, so you find an excuse to not give it. This avoidance provides temporary relief, but it also reinforces the original negative prediction. Your mind concludes, "I avoided the presentation, and I didn't fail. My prediction was right." This strengthens the belief that your future-casting ability is accurate, making it even more likely that you'll engage in fortune telling and avoidance the next time you face a similar situation. This cycle keeps you from confronting your fears and discovering that the feared outcomes were not inevitable.
Hypothetical Scenario Imagine you have an important job interview next week. You have all the qualifications and have prepared thoroughly. Yet, you find yourself thinking, “I’m going to completely mess it up. They’re going to ask a question I don’t know, and I’ll stumble over my words, and they’ll think I’m not qualified.” You feel a deep sense of dread and anxiety whenever you think about the interview. Your mind is already replaying the scene of your failure, even though it hasn't happened. This preemptive thinking makes you less confident, and you might even start to question your abilities, which can, in turn, affect your actual performance. Your feelings and thoughts are not based on any evidence, but on a prediction you have made about the future, which is exactly the hallmark of fortune telling. You might find yourself dreading the day of the interview, sleeping poorly, and feeling a constant low-level panic. You become so convinced of your failure that you consider calling in sick or even withdrawing your application, demonstrating how the distortion can lead directly to avoidance.
How Others Perceive You
Fortune telling doesn't just affect your inner world; it also influences your interactions with others, shaping how you are perceived and responded to in social and professional environments. When you engage in this distortion, your negative predictions can become a source of frustration, confusion, and even emotional distance for those around you. Your persistent negativity can be a subtle but significant force that pushes people away.
Social Interactions In social interactions, fortune telling can be perceived as an unwillingness to engage or an overly negative outlook. When you consistently predict negative outcomes for social events, friends and family might start to feel drained or even dismissed. For example, if a group is discussing plans for a weekend trip and you say, “We’ll never find a good place to stay, it’s not worth looking,” you might be perceived as a killjoy who is determined to shut down the fun before it begins. This can lead to others feeling discouraged or even avoiding making plans with you because they anticipate your negative input. Over time, your friends might stop asking for your opinion on new ideas, creating a feedback loop where you feel excluded, which may, in turn, reinforce your belief that people don't want you around.
Perceptions by Others People around you may interpret your fortune-telling as a form of pessimism, a lack of self-confidence, or a reluctance to take action. When you vocalize your negative predictions, others may not understand the underlying anxiety and instead see it as a statement of fact or a personal attack on their ideas. This can create a dynamic where others feel they must constantly reassure you, which can become exhausting. For instance, in a team meeting, if you repeatedly state, "This new project is going to fail," your colleagues might see you as unmotivated or apathetic, rather than as someone struggling with a cognitive distortion. They might start to feel that their enthusiasm is being met with a wall of negativity, which can lead to resentment and a breakdown in collaboration.
Balanced Perspective While fortune telling is primarily a negative distortion, understanding how others perceive it can provide a balanced perspective.
Positive Outcomes: Perceived as Thoughtful or Cautious In some instances, your preemptive thinking might be misinterpreted as a form of careful planning or a cautious approach. For example, in a work environment, if you voice a potential problem with a project, it might be seen as you being thoughtful and considering all the angles, rather than as a negative prediction. A colleague might say, "That's a good point, we should make a contingency plan for that." This can be a subtle distinction, but in certain contexts, it can be viewed as a positive attribute. However, the line between caution and fortune telling is thin; caution is based on evidence and preparation, whereas fortune telling is based on fear and unfounded certainty.
Negative Outcomes: Social Isolation and Misunderstandings The negative outcomes, however, are far more common. The constant negative predictions can lead to a form of social isolation. When people feel that you are always expecting the worst, they might stop sharing their good news with you, or they may feel that they cannot rely on you for support. This can create a distance between you and your loved ones or colleagues, leading to misunderstandings and a sense of alienation. Your negative predictions can also become a burden on others, as they feel responsible for your emotional well-being, which can cause strain on the relationship. A friend might eventually say, "I just can't listen to all the negativity anymore," which can be a painful but honest consequence of this distortion.
By being mindful of how your internal thoughts manifest in external communication, you can better manage this distortion and improve your relationships with others.
Reel-Life Realities: Movie Character Cognitive Distortions
Movie Overview The Secret Life of Walter Mitty is a film that tells the story of Walter Mitty, a timid and unremarkable photo editor at Life magazine. Walter frequently daydreams of a life of adventure, but in his reality, he struggles with confidence and inaction. His world is turned upside down when a crucial photo negative goes missing, forcing him to embark on a real-life adventure to find it. The film is a journey of self-discovery, where Walter must learn to overcome his fears and embrace the unpredictable nature of life.
Character Identification Walter Mitty, played by Ben Stiller, is the protagonist of the film. He is a shy and introverted man who works a monotonous job, and his inner life is far more vibrant than his external one. He is defined by his fear of the unknown and his tendency to withdraw from real-life opportunities. This internal conflict between his desire for adventure and his fear of failure is the central theme of his character arc.
Specific Scene Early in the movie, Walter has to face the new corporate managers of Life magazine and deliver a presentation. Despite having all the information and the opportunity to prepare, Walter stands in a hallway and mentally predicts his own failure. He imagines himself giving a terrible presentation, stumbling over his words, and being completely humiliated. His negative forecast is so vivid that he almost retreats from the situation entirely, needing to be gently nudged into the room by a friend. This scene perfectly captures the paralysis that fortune telling can cause.
Analysis of Distortions This specific scene is a textbook example of fortune telling. Walter, without any evidence or prior failure, is certain that he will fail. He is not just nervous; he has already decided on the outcome. This thought process prevents him from seeing a path to success. Instead of focusing on the fact that he has prepared and has the necessary skills, he is consumed by a fear of the future. The movie shows that Walter's fortune telling is a major factor holding him back from living a more fulfilled life, as he consistently predicts negative outcomes and, as a result, avoids taking chances. This scene also serves as a critical turning point in the film. It shows how debilitating his fear is, but it also sets the stage for his eventual transformation as he is forced to confront real-life challenges without the luxury of his negative predictions. By the end of the film, he is no longer a fortune teller, but a man who embraces the unknown.
Daily Manifestations of Fortune Telling
Fortune telling can infiltrate the fabric of your daily life, influencing how you approach a wide range of situations. From the mundane to the momentous, this distortion can color your perception of reality and limit your actions. This section provides specific examples of how fortune telling might manifest across various contexts.
Social Interactions In social settings, fortune telling can be a major source of anxiety. You might be invited to a get-together and immediately think, “I’ll be awkward, and no one will want to talk to me.” This negative prediction can cause you to feel anxious before you even leave your house and may even lead you to cancel your plans. Similarly, if you send a text to a friend and they don’t reply immediately, you might conclude, “They must be angry with me,” rather than considering that they could just be busy. This type of thinking can prevent you from initiating new friendships or deepening existing ones, as you become so focused on the feared outcome that you fail to see the potential for a positive interaction.
Work Environments In the workplace, fortune telling can be a significant barrier to professional growth. If a new project is announced, you might think, "I'm going to fail at this," before you have even had a chance to understand the requirements. This can lead to a lack of motivation or even a refusal to take on new challenges, as you have already decided on the outcome. Before a meeting with your manager, you might predict, “They are going to criticize my performance,” even when you have received no indication of any issues. This can cause unnecessary stress and a defensive posture during the meeting, making you appear unapproachable and closed off to feedback. This distortion can also lead to missed opportunities, as you may not apply for a promotion because you’ve already convinced yourself you won't get it.
Personal Goals When pursuing personal goals, fortune telling can derail your progress before it even begins. If you are trying to learn a new skill, like playing the guitar, you might tell yourself after a week of practice, “I’ll never be good at this.” This belief can cause you to give up prematurely, preventing you from ever reaching your full potential. Similarly, if you are working towards a fitness goal and have a setback, you might predict, “I’m going to fail to lose the weight,” rather than seeing it as a minor hurdle to overcome. This kind of thinking can lead to a sense of helplessness and can prevent you from achieving your goals. Fortune telling can also manifest in relationships. If you have a minor disagreement with your partner, you might immediately think, “This is the beginning of the end,” rather than seeing it as a normal part of a healthy relationship. This can cause you to act in a way that creates distance, inadvertently making your negative prediction a reality.
By recognizing these daily manifestations of fortune telling, you can begin to catch yourself in the act of making negative predictions. This awareness is crucial for challenging these thoughts and developing a more balanced, evidence-based approach to your life.
20 Signs to Watch Out For
Here is a list of 20 common thoughts or phrases that are often indicators of fortune telling. If you catch yourself saying or thinking these, it's a sign that you might be engaging in this cognitive distortion:
"I know this is going to end badly."
"What's the point? It won't work out anyway."
"They won't be interested in what I have to say."
"I'm going to fail this exam."
"Nobody will show up."
"I'm not going to get the job."
"This is a waste of time."
"My presentation will be a disaster."
"He/she is going to say no."
"I'll just embarrass myself."
"This relationship won't last."
"They're going to think I'm stupid."
"I'll never be able to do this."
"My friends won't like my idea."
"I'm going to get sick right before the trip."
"This project is doomed from the start."
"The other team will definitely win."
"I'm going to mess up my diet."
"The feedback is going to be terrible."
"This problem is unsolvable."
Additional Resources
In a world where personal exploration and self-understanding are pivotal, embarking on a journey through collaborative assessment stands as a deeply enriching endeavor. As your experienced guide in this transformative process, I am dedicated to facilitating a deeper dive into your personal narrative, helping unveil the intricate layers of your individuality and fostering a pathway to authentic self-discovery and growth.
Individual Therapy: Personalized Psychological Support If you're seeking transformative psychological support, my specialized service is here for you. I cater to a diverse range of clients - from those grappling with emotional challenges, students navigating the pressures of college life, to high-achieving professionals seeking balance. My approach is tailored to your unique needs, fostering wellness, equilibrium, and a profound understanding of your inner self.
Couples Therapy: Strengthening Relationships Together For couples, therapy is a brave journey towards a more harmonious and fulfilling union. Embark on this transformative process with your partner, where you'll explore the complexities of your relationship together. Address underlying issues, strengthen your bond, and grow closer than ever before in a collaborative and supportive environment.
